Australia is weighing an AI opt-out copyright model. Under it, AI companies could train on work Australians publish online unless each rights holder objects. Now artists in Grayndler, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s own electorate in Sydney’s inner west, have come out against it, The Guardian reports. If you write, license or train on music in Australia, the draft rules arrive within weeks. Below you’ll find the full timeline, why opt-out is especially awkward for songs, and what to do before the bills land.


The AI opt-out copyright idea in one paragraph
Australian copyright runs on permission. Want to use someone’s work? Ask first. An AI opt-out flips that copyright default, so the company can use the work and the owner has to say no, somewhere, in some format, before the training run starts. The creator does the paperwork. The company keeps the default. (Opt-out sounds like a choice. Mostly it’s a chore.)
What happened so far
The story has been building for a year. Here it is in order.
In 2025, the Productivity Commission’s interim report floated a text and data mining exception, a legal carve-out that lets software copy and analyse works for training. Tech firms backed it. Creative groups hated it.
On 27 October 2025, Attorney-General Michelle Rowland ruled the exception out and said the government had no plans to weaken copyright protection for AI, per iTnews. APRA AMCOS, ARIA, the Australian Society of Authors and Screenrights welcomed the call. The government also set up a Copyright and AI Reference Group to look for legal routes to training.
In early September 2026, the government ran confidential consultations. On 15 September the ABC revealed leaked slides with two options. Under the first, AI firms get permission after striking a minimum number of deals with rights holders. The second has them pay a central body, or separate organisations representing music or writing creators. Both would turn copyright into an opt-out system for AI training.
That same week, executives from OpenAI and Anthropic met federal ministers. Rowland’s office said it was consulting on giving creators “control and fair payment”.
On 22 September 2026, Forbes Australia reported that Anthropic’s submission to a parliamentary inquiry asked the government to “permit AI model training through a narrow form of conditional approval”, with creators keeping an option to refuse.
On 31 October 2026, Coalition senators and the recording industry warned that an opt-out could breach the constitution (The Guardian). On 1 November, Grayndler artists and creative businesses spoke out against the model (The Guardian), and a report commissioned by ARIA called big tech’s national security case for weaker copyright a bluff (The Sydney Morning Herald). On 8 November, the global recording industry body IFPI warned Albanese that weakening the law would be a “disaster for creativity” (The Guardian). The government has made no decision yet: a spokesperson for Rowland said any future copyright changes would “deliver meaningful control and fair compensation”. Next come the draft bills, due by the end of the year, then a parliamentary debate in 2027.
On 10 November the fight reached the Prime Minister by name. Jimmy Barnes had attacked the proposed copyright changes on Nine’s Today show and, as the ABC put it, suggested the AI companies should “go and f*** themselves” (ABC News). Asked at a Parliament House press conference whether the AI package would weaken current copyright law, Albanese replied: “Jimmy Barnes needs to be clearer about his view on these things, and he shouldn’t beat around the bush” (transcript).
Then he sent Barnes back to his July speech and restated two principles: “One, that artists need to have control over their work. And secondly, that they need to be compensated if their work is used.” In July he had promised that “No company should use Australian books, music, art or news to build or train AI without the artist’s control” (ABC News). “My position certainly hasn’t changed on any of that,” he said. He did not answer the yes-or-no part of the question. Control plus payment is also close to how Rowland’s office describes the options on the table, so the reassurance settles less than it sounds.
The same day the government announced mandatory AI safety standards and a new AI safety regulator, and Albanese said the national AI standards are due to be unveiled by the end of this year (ABC live blog). The copyright detail is still not public.
Grayndler artists say an AI opt-out turns them into a resource
Grayndler is an odd place to test this. According to The Guardian, the seat has more than 3,000 cultural and creative businesses. Creative work employs 10% of its workers, against 4.2% nationally. So the Prime Minister’s own constituents are more than twice as likely as the average Australian to be the people whose work goes into the model. Few seats have more to lose from an AI copyright opt-out.
One artist and designer uses AI in her own practice. She still called it unacceptable to make authors opt out themselves, because that turns them into a resource for tech companies. Notice who is saying it. She has no quarrel with the tools; her quarrel is with the default.
H Morgan-Harris, curator and director of the art space Tortuga Studios, warned that Australia’s creative ecosystem could suffer significant harm. Jason Zoidberg, co-founder of Monster Mouse Studios, also criticised handing AI firms that access. Still, he noted rising interest in hands-on workshops across Sydney’s west. Some people are answering the robots by learning to screenprint.
Albanese has said creators need the strongest possible protections, and that using their work without paying would be theft. Meanwhile, Coalition senators and music industry figures warn that an opt-out could amount to the state taking property. Australia’s constitution only allows that on just terms. That argument will outlive the press cycle.
Update, 2 November: the constitutional point now has a legal opinion behind it. Constitutional expert Anne Twomey told Guardian Australia there is “potentially” a problem, depending on how the law is drafted, if letting AI firms scrape copyrighted work counts as the government acquiring property. Section 51 of the constitution allows that only “on just terms”. The Attorney-General’s Department said it was “extremely alive” to the issue. Nationals senator Ross Cadell, who sits on the parliamentary committee on AI, warned the government “could be liable for ‘just terms’ compensation for acquiring that property for every rights holder on Earth”. ARIA chief executive Annabelle Herd called scraping “clearly an acquisition of property”.
Voters lean the same way. In polling of 1,524 Australian adults by RedBridge Group, released by ARIA and reported again on 9 November, 78% wanted to keep the rule that AI companies need permission to use creative work, and 9% wanted the law changed (IT Brief Australia). 74% said creators should decide whether their work is used to train AI models. Even among the 33% who support AI companies training models in Australia, 82% said the same. And 52% said they would be more likely to back a party that keeps the permission rule, against 14% less likely. That last number is the one a prime minister reads twice.
Why an AI copyright opt-out is awkward for music
A novel usually has one author and one publisher. A song has a crowd: the songwriter, the co-writers, the publisher, the label that owns the recording, the distributor, and sometimes a sample owner from 1974. Then the song spreads. Streaming services, lyric sites, fan uploads, a cover on someone else’s channel, a TikTok with the track sped up 1.25x.
So any AI opt-out written into copyright law has to answer a boring question first. Opt out where? The usual tool is robots.txt, a small text file that tells web crawlers to stay away. It only covers the sites you control, though. A songwriter can block her own website, but not every repost of her chorus. As law academic Dilan Thampapillai argued, the timing fails too. Once a work is inside a model, the model can’t unlearn it, so a late opt-out does nothing.
Try this with any track you uploaded five years ago. Search the title, count the mirror sites, and stop when you reach the one with a cookie banner that never closes. Anyway.
The leaked second option actually fits music better. Paying organisations that represent music creators describes collecting societies, which already license songs to radio, venues and streaming. That model has decades of plumbing behind it. An opt-out registry would start from nothing, and the people with the least spare time would have to maintain it.


What we think: an opt-out is a chore dressed as a choice
Our view is plain. Opt-in is how music copyright already works, and an AI opt-out would make training the one use that skips the asking. Find the owner, agree terms, pay. If a company wants a song’s data, the song’s owners should get a yes-or-no moment and a cheque, rather than a crawler they have to find and block.
We’d say that even if it didn’t suit us. It does, though. Mubert generates music from samples that artists upload through its Studio and get paid for. Consent sits in the supply chain from the first loop, so nobody has to opt out of anything. It costs money and needs contracts, which is apparently the bit some business models would like to skip.
The investment argument deserves a fair hearing. OpenAI told the inquiry that copyright policy is “part of that investment environment”. But Michaelia Cash’s reply, quoted by the ABC, is hard to beat: “you do not attract investment by simply giving away Australians’ intellectual property.” If you want a data centre, there are cleaner ways to pay for one than with someone else’s songs.
IFPI chief executive Victoria Oakley took the investment argument head on. “I just don’t think it’s true that you will only get investment or growth, or be seen as pro-innovation, if you entirely give in to the demands of AI companies,” she told Guardian Australia. Her bigger worry is contagion: “You just need one safe harbour, because then you can train on music from anywhere in the world.” OpenAI had told the parliamentary committee on AI that Spotify licenses music because it streams it untransformed. Oakley’s reply is that labels have already signed dozens of licensing deals with smaller AI companies. “It is perfectly possible to license,” she said.
The national security version of the argument took a hit on 1 November. A report by Strategic Analysis Australia, written by former Australian Signals Directorate deputy director Michael Shoebridge and commissioned by ARIA, says AI firms are dressing up commercial demands as security needs (The Sydney Morning Herald). “AI for national security does not need Powderfinger’s back catalogue,” he said. His report argues agencies can already buy advanced AI commercially, and that training American-owned models here would not give Australia ownership of them. David Wroe of Good Ancestors, a group that has received philanthropic funds with ties to Anthropic, disagreed: Australia gets more leverage over access to frontier models if they are trained locally.
The fight also has a music case on file already. Publishers say AI models already trained on Kylie Minogue songs. So whatever AI copyright rule Australia picks, opt-out or not, it arrives with a bill for training that already happened.
What creators can do before the AI opt-out copyright drafts arrive
Draft bills on AI copyright, opt-out options included, are due within weeks. Some of this is worth doing now.
- Register your songs with your collecting society (APRA AMCOS in Australia) and keep your metadata clean, since every licensing option needs to know who owns what.
- Write to your federal MP, especially in a seat where creative work is a big share of local jobs. Grayndler got noticed.
- Block AI crawlers on the sites you control. It won’t cover everything, but it puts your refusal on record.
- Read your distributor’s and label’s terms for any clause about AI training or licensing your catalogue to third parties.
- If you use AI music in your videos or products, check where the training data came from and what the licence covers.
The government says it wants to give creators control. In Grayndler, people have already worked out what control looks like under an AI opt-out copyright rule.
Homework.



